What is ethical sourcing?
Source ethically with IBM Sterling Subscribe for sustainability updates
Illustration of complex supply chain elements

Published: 23 January 2024
Contributors: Alexandra Jonker

What is ethical sourcing?

Ethical sourcing ensures suppliers and vendors meet certain ethical standards, such as upholding fair labor practices, making a positive social impact and practicing environmental sustainability. Implementing ethical sourcing often requires organizations to set standardized sourcing policies and do their due diligence on prospective suppliers.

Sourcing is the process of identifying, evaluating and selecting suppliers to provide raw materials and services. It is one of the first steps of supply chain management—the handling of the entire production flow of a good or service. Frequently used interchangeably with “procurement,” sourcing is a distinct supply chain process within the procurement department. Due to their interconnection, sourcing and procurement strategies typically share similar goals and metrics, including ethical considerations.

Ethical sourcing is core to the concept of corporate social responsibility (CSR), or the idea that businesses should operate according to principles and policies that make a positive impact on society and the environment. It’s also key to organizations who follow the “triple bottom line” framework, which suggests that business outcomes should not be measured by only the financial bottom line. Instead, they must also consider the well-being of people and the planet.

7 sustainability trends to take action on

Take a look at the trends shaping the world of sustainable business and the insights that can help drive transformation.

Related content

Register for the playbook on smarter asset management

Ethical sourcing vs. responsible sourcing

Responsible sourcing is the process of considering the social, economic and environmental impacts of all sourcing activities and suppliers. Organizations that practice responsible sourcing take responsibility for what happens in the product lifecycle—from carbon emissions to workers’ rights.

In sustainable sourcing and sustainable procurement, a greater emphasis is placed on the environmental impacts of suppliers and vendors. These processes fall under the umbrella of responsible sourcing. The same is true for ethical sourcing, which encompasses both environmental and social impacts of the entire supply chain.

What makes a supplier or vendor unethical?

There is not yet a universal, codified set of standards for ethical sourcing; those practicing ethical sourcing may have a wide range of ethical considerations. There are, however, some legislative laws and policies that touch on ethical sourcing. For example, the UK Modern Slavery Act, the California Transparency in Supply Chains Act and National Action Plans (NAPs) on Business and Human Rights across several continents including South America, Europe, Africa and Asia.

It’s important to note that suppliers or vendors can claim to be ethical in one regard (such as being organic, fair trade of cruelty-free certified) but may not be ethical across their entire operations and global supply chains.

In general, an unethical supplier or vendor is one that:

Has a negative impact on the environment

This includes suppliers and vendors who produce high levels of carbon emissions, contribute to deforestation, mistreat animals, mismanage waste and more.

Operates dishonestly

Deceitful suppliers or vendors might purposefully withhold or hide contract information; lie to customers and partners about product quality, origins or ingredients; or engage in bribery and the misuse of trade secrets.

Exploits workers

Failure to adhere to fair labor practices may include not paying a fair wage, using human trafficking or child labor as well as not providing adequate or safe working conditions.

What are the benefits of ethical sourcing?

Outside of ethical sourcing being good for people and the planet, there are strong arguments for its tangible business benefits as well:

Competitive advantage

Upholding a strong ethical sourcing policy can boost an organization’s brand reputation. In recent years, customers have become more purpose-driven, choosing products and brands based on how well they align to their values. In fact, they now represent the largest market segment (44%). These consumers are savvy and willing to examine business practices to ensure a brand upholds its promises in areas such as sustainability and the fight against climate change as well as human rights. If consumers are satisfied with what they find, they are more likely to choose that brand over competitors with cheaper price points.

Cost reduction

A 2015 report from the World Economic Forum suggests that ethical sourcing practices could decrease supply chain costs up to 16%.1 Multiple ethical sourcing practices could contribute to this decrease, such as reducing transportation costs by sourcing locally or cutting operating costs by switching to more energy efficient or renewable energy sources.

Regulatory compliance

Ethical sourcing can be a stepping stone toward following new and existing legislation mandating transparency around the impact of an organization’s environmental, social and governance (ESG) initiatives. For example, the European Union’s (EU) Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) requires that companies disclose their due diligence process for identifying and mitigating the social and environmental impacts in their value chains and supply chains.

How are organizations upholding ethical sourcing?

Since there are no official standards or codes that guide ethical sourcing practices, the way an organization builds its own ethical sourcing program is unique. However, many organizations start by establishing a strong vetting process and then upholding their standards with ongoing audits.

To develop a vetting process, organizations may look to competitors for examples of similar ethics policies, codes of conduct and best practices. Then, companies may use this information, as well as their own existing policies around practices like sustainability, to build criteria for evaluating potential suppliers. If there are none, organizations can consult reputable outside policies, such as the United Nations Guiding Principles for Business and Human Rights. Then, organizations can incorporate these standards—and how non-compliance will be addressed—right into supplier contracts.

Organizations should be prepared for the potential that a supplier may engage in unethical practices at any time, no matter their past performance. Therefore, organizations may choose to monitor supplier practices throughout the duration of a contract. Continual audits ensure compliance to contractual agreements around ethics and allow organizations to identify areas for improvement, set goals and initiate corrective action.

Ethical sourcing and supply chain risk management (SCRM) software

Supply chain risk management (SCRM) software helps organizations find the right suppliers and uphold their ethical sourcing policies. SCRM software often provides real-time supplier visibility and incorporates reliable supplier information and data from industry-recognized validators to reduce risk. Some offer powerful analytics and artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities for continuous monitoring of suppliers’ regulatory compliance. Features may include:

Built-in global and industry standards

Cross-industry standardized questionnaires, metrics and workflows that can reduce risk, including cyber threats.

Third-party compliance validators

Supplier risk management strategy integrates with data sets from authoritative third parties to reduce risk.

Automated profile management

Supplier and third-party information automatically update for all interested parties.

Continuous market monitoring

Automation ensures supplier risk assessment data is current with the market.

Advanced analytics

Analytics capabilities manage decision-making, onboarding, contingency plans and lifecycle processes, including reporting and audit management.

Blockchain information management

Security, transparency and traceability for supplier data reduces operational risk.

Related solutions
IBM Sterling Supply Chain Intelligence Suite

Apply the power of artificial intelligence (AI) and the speed of automation to improve supply chain management, resiliency and sustainability.

Explore the IBM Sterling Supply Chain Intelligence Suite

IBM Food Trust

Leverage a modular solution built on blockchain to benefit all network participants with a safer, smarter and more sustainable food ecosystem.

Explore IBM Food Trust

IBM Supply Chain Control Tower

Orchestrate your end-to-end supply chain with real-time visibility and actionable workflows powered by artificial intelligence and machine learning.

Explore IBM® Supply Chain Control Tower

IBM Sterling Transparent Supply

Build your own blockchain ecosystem with traceability software for better supply chain management.

Explore the IBM Sterling Transparent Supply
Resources IBM Blockchain Transparent Supply

Discover how to build your own blockchain-enabled collaboration and data-sharing ecosystem with your supply chain partners.

IDC Technology Spotlight

Learn about the benefits of the Modern Control Tower—a hub to encompass the entire supply chain beyond just logistics and fulfillment.

IBM Supply Chain Control Tower Demo

See how IBM Supply Chain Control Tower allows you to respond faster to changes, enable efficient collaboration, and drive operational automation.

What is the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD)?

The CSRD is European Union legislation that requires businesses to report on the environmental and social impact of their business activities, and on the business impact of their ESG efforts.

What is corporate social responsibility (CSR)?

Corporate social responsibility (CSR) is the idea that businesses should operate according to principles and policies that make a positive impact on society and the environment.

What is supply chain management?

Supply chain management is the handling of the entire production flow of a good or service—starting from the raw components all the way to delivering the final product to the consumer.

Take the next step

IBM Sterling Supply Chain Intelligence Suite is an AI-based optimization and automation solution. Designed for organizations struggling to solve supply chain disruptions through traditional transformation, the suite facilitates supply network resiliency and sustainability, increases agility and accelerates time-to-value through actionable insights, smarter workflows and intelligent automation.

Explore Supply Chain Intelligence Suite Try free for 30 days
Footnotes

Beyond Supply Chains Empowering Responsible Value Chains” (link resides outside ibm.com), World Economic Forum, January 2015