As its business grew, I-MED realized that its existing systems were too inflexible to support the sophisticated financial and operational planning processes the company will need for the future.
I-MED worked with Cornerstone, an IBM Business Partner, to build a new planning model that would support detailed, activity-based budgeting at the clinic level for faster budgeting and forecasting.
Savesa week of work for each commercial manager during the budgeting cycle
Automatesmanual, spreadsheet-based processes, reducing the risk of errors
Eliminatesa three-hour wait for budget figures to refresh, providing instant insight
Business challenge story
Diagnosing growing pains
As healthcare costs continue to rise in many global economies, both public and private healthcare organizations need to find more cost-effective ways to deliver services, while maintaining the highest possible quality of care.
One way of achieving this has been through growth and clinic expansion to achieve economies of scale. In recent years, this business model has helped I-MED Radiology Network become one of the leading players in the Australian radiology services sector. Formed in 2000, I-MED has grown both organically and through acquisition, and now operates 185 clinics across five states.
From a financial and operational perspective, however, this growth was beginning to create challenges for the company, as Lisa Smith, Commercial Manager at I-MED, explains.
“One of our strengths as a business is that we give each of our business units the autonomy to do things its own way. That’s an operational advantage, but it makes things a little more complicated for group-level planning and analysis.
“Moreover, the planning process itself was already complex enough. For example, to assess our P&L effectively, we need to forecast not only the number of procedures we will perform each day at each clinic, but also the type of procedure, and whether it is being paid for by private insurance or through Medicare.”
As a result of this complexity, the company’s existing financial planning processes were beginning to struggle. Many of the steps required to build budgets or calculate salaries needed to be done in spreadsheets, and then re-loaded back into the central planning system—a time-consuming and potentially error-prone process.
“We wanted to upgrade to a more modern platform that would not only help us streamline financial planning and analysis, but also unlock the potential for more operational planning and reporting,” says Lisa Smith.
Achieving X-ray vision
As a first step, I-MED began looking for a solution that could act as a direct replacement for its existing planning system. However, when Cornerstone, an IBM Business Partner that specializes in financial planning and analytics solutions, demonstrated the full capabilities of IBM® Planning Analytics Express software (known at the time as IBM Cognos® Express), the company’s decision-makers quickly recognized its potential to improve both financial and operational planning processes.
“I had used planning and analytics software from IBM in previous roles at other companies, so when I heard that we had selected Planning Analytics Express, I was very pleased,” says Lisa Smith. “I knew it would let us build a model that was tailored to the unique needs of our business, instead of having to adapt to an off-the-shelf solution—which was critical, given the complexity and diversity of our company.”
I-MED decided to work with Cornerstone to help develop and implement the new planning model. Piers Wilson, Director at Cornerstone, says: “There is a great relationship between our team and I-MED and it was very satisfying that the team not only provided great value to I-MED, but also delivered the project within a tight timeframe and under budget.”
Lisa Smith adds: “Working with Cornerstone was fantastic—they were very flexible and responsive, and they quickly understood the challenges of building a model that would meet our needs. Their technical skills were excellent, but more importantly, we felt that they were talking our language.”
With a relatively tight deadline to get the new system up and running before the next annual budgeting cycle began, the I-MED and Cornerstone teams worked closely together to design, build and deploy the new model, and to train users.
“Planning Analytics Express allows you to use Microsoft Excel as a user interface, which is a big advantage,” says Lisa Smith. “It’s a very familiar, user-friendly environment for finance people to work in. At the same time, your model, calculations and data are all held securely in the solution’s database, so you can avoid most of the errors that happen with spreadsheets, and there’s no need to keep importing and exporting data from one system to another, which saves a lot of time.”
The first priority was to develop the annual budgeting process, which was delivered under budget and on schedule within just four months. Next, the team began working on a billing model for the tele-radiology business unit—replacing a large, complex spreadsheet that took minutes to open, and sometimes even crashed users’ PCs.
“Looking ahead, we’d like to bring more operational data into our model—there’s a lot of potential to model payroll and equipment in Planning Analytics Express too,” says Lisa Smith. “The system is flexible enough to develop all kinds of analytical applications, so we see a lot of potential to keep expanding our capabilities in the future.”
A healthier outlook
The first major test of the new solution was to handle I-MED’s annual budgeting process; and, according to feedback from the company’s users, Planning Analytics Express passed with flying colors.
Lisa Smith recalls: “Our process is for each business unit to prepare its own budget, then present the results to our CFO and make any adjustments necessary before we present the final version to the board.
“In previous years, the lead up to the presentation to our CFO has been somewhat rushed: we had to make adjustments, wait until the numbers were updated in the system, and then review and make more adjustments if necessary. Working with multiple spreadsheets also meant we always had to double-check our calculations, which took even more time.
“By contrast, with Planning Analytics Express, we had done such a thorough job on testing the new model that we were confident the logic was correct, and the results for this year’s budget all checked out as expected without needing significant manual adjustment.”
She adds: “I’ve spoken to the other commercial managers in the business, and we estimate that Planning Analytics Express saved us about a week of work each over the course of the budgeting cycle.”
A key contributing factor to this time-saving is the fact that when an adjustment is made in Planning Analytics Express, the whole budget is recalculated automatically, within seconds. Previously, users had to download their data into spreadsheets, work on their adjustments, and then re-load the new data back into the old system’s models. The loading process took about 20 minutes, during which time users could not access the system. As a result, the team was only able to refresh the data periodically—which made it difficult to correct errors quickly.
“If you made a mistake and didn’t realize, you only found out about it during the next refresh; and once you had corrected it, you then had to wait up to three hours for the model to update,” says Lisa Smith. “With Planning Analytics Express, when you change your input, you see the impact instantly, so you can update your budget in minutes instead of hours.”
In the near future, I-MED will also launch its new billing model for the tele-radiology business unit, which will enable it to retire one of its largest and most complex spreadsheets.
“We’re really looking forward to harnessing the robustness and speed of Planning Analytics Express to manage our billing process,” says Lisa Smith. “We’re also in the process of loading our actuals regularly, so we’ll be able to do reporting on our key performance indicators [KPIs] entirely in the system, instead of breaking it out into spreadsheets.”
She concludes: “IBM Planning Analytics Express gives us so much flexibility to model different aspects of our business, and we are looking forward to taking the next steps of our journey. By improving both financial and operational planning and reporting, we’re putting the company in a strong position to support sustainable growth.”
I-MED Radiology Network
I-MED Radiology is Australia’s largest medical imaging network, with 185 clinics across all major metropolitan areas and significant parts of rural and regional Australia. Annually, over 4.2 million patient procedures are performed by its 250 specialist radiologists and approximately 3,000 staff, making it one of the largest providers in the world. I-MED also provides I-TeleRAD, a sophisticated teleradiology reporting service.
- Cognos Express
- Cognos TM1
- HC: Health Data & Insights
- Planning Analytics
Take the next step
IBM Analytics offers one of the world's deepest and broadest analytics platform, domain and industry solutions that deliver new value to businesses, governments and individuals. For more information about how IBM Analytics helps to transform industries and professions with data, visit ibm.com/analytics. Follow us on Twitter at @IBMAnalytics, on our blog at ibmbigdatahub.com and join the conversation #IBMAnalytics.
Cornerstone is an IBM Gold Business Partner specializing in performance management solutions covering budgeting and forecasting, business intelligence and information management. Founded in 2007 and bringing together over 200 years of consulting experience, Cornerstone operates in Australia and across Asia, and is one of the largest IBM Analytics-focused partners in the Asia-Pacific market.