HD07430: ITEV5CV5 : DUPLICATION OF EXISTING PART WITH í ù IN LCA

APAR status

• Closed as Permanent restriction.

Error description

• ITEV5CV5 : DUPLICATION OF EXISTING PART WITH ￭  IN LCA
  
  SCENARIO :
  -----------------
  Legend : COMPx are ENOVIA LCA part reference object.
           PARTx  are ENOVIA LCA part reference object with a
  CATPart document as representation.
  
  1) In ENOVIA LCA  create an empty PRC '2D_PRODUCT_COMP1'
  2) In ENOVIA LCA  create the following PRC 'ASSEMBLY'
  Exploded LCA Structure :PRC 'ASSEMBLY'
  PRC
    |_ COMP1
    |   |_ COMP2
    |   |     |_ PART1
    |   |     |_ PART2
    |   |_ COMP3
    |        |_ PART3
    |        |_ PART4
    |_ COMP4
  
  2) From LCA  load the assembly COMP1 (for which cust wants
  to create an assembly drawing) in CATIA V5.
  CATIA V5 PRC window session:
  PRC
    |_ COMP1
       |_ COMP2
       |     |_ PART1
       |     |_ PART2
       |_ COMP3
            |_ PART3
            |_ PART4
  
  3) From ENOVIA LCA, load the empty PRC '2D_PRODUCT_COMP1'
  4) In CATIA V5 PRC window copy the COMP1 assembly and paste
  it (break links) under the CATProduct  '2D_PRODUCT_COMP1'.
  
  CATA V5 2D_PRODUCT_COMP1 window session:
  2D_PRODUCT_COMP
    |_ COMP1
       |_ COMP2
       |     |_ PART1
       |     |_ PART2
       |_ COMP3
            |_ PART3
            |_ PART4
  5) From CATIA V5, save the CATProduct (2D_PRODUCT_COMP1) in
  ENOVIA LCA.
  
  2D_PRODUCT_COMP1 to which
  the .CATProduct document is attached. ---> OK
  -COMP1, COMP2 & COMP3 are duplicated in LCA (with ￭1 added
  to thier part number). ---> KO
  -PART1, PART2, PART3,  &  PART4 are not duplicated. ---> OK
  
  EXPECTED RESULT :
  ---------------
  - Since COMP1, COMP2 & COMP3 were loaded from ENOVIA, the
  system must not recreate them  with ￭1 at the saving of the
  product (2D_PRODUCT_COMP1). The behavior should be the same
  as the PART1, PART2, PART3,  &  PART4.
  

Local fix

Problem summary

• DUPLICATION OF EXISTING PART WITH 0 ' IN LCA
  *DS
  JQD on 04 Jun.
  ===============
  
  
  
  
  
  <table border="0" cellSpacing="0"><tr><td  class="tdComment">De
  scription</td></tr></table> ===================================
  ===============================
   |                       INFORMATIONS FOR AIX OS
  
   ==============================================================
  ====
  *DESCRIPTION
  
  ITEV5CV5 : DUPLICATION OF EXISTING PART WITH     IN LCA
  

Problem conclusion

• THIS PROBLEM IS PERMANENT RESTRICTION IN ENOVIA.
  
  These are the reasons of the PRS part:
  
  This is the intended behaviour in V5
  - On a Paste Break Link, the new entity is created
  for the topmost here COMP1
  - This creation of new entities is extended to
  embedded component, here COMP2
  - But the creation of new entities is not expended
  to other sub entities if they have a stand alone
  definition. Hence a new part is not created for
  PART1. And if COMP2 was a product and a
  component, COMP2 would not be created new
  either.
  
  There is no other solution than that as long as you
  are using components. This because a component
  defined in the product PRC can not be instanciated
  in anothe product, here 2D_PRC.
  
  
  That's why it may be considered FIN and fixed in
  R12 With the "Elementary Part" developement in R12, assemblies
  created as CATProduct in CATIA and saved exploded in ENOVIA are
   restored as
  CATProduct in CATIA (in R10 / R11 they come
  back as CATComponent).
  
  This will let you share product between the 2 distinct PRC by a
   simple Copy / Paste (without
  break link)
  
  .
  

Temporary fix

Comments

APAR Information

• APAR is sysrouted FROM one or more of the following:

• APAR is sysrouted TO one or more of the following:

Fix information

Applicable component levels