HD99019: ASSEMBLY: PUBLISHED AXIS CANNOT BE SELECTED FOR A COINCIDENCE CO NSTRAINT WHEN "USE PUBLISHED GEOMETRY OF ANY LEVEL" IS ON

APAR status

• Closed as unreproducible in next release.

Error description

• Scenario:
  1. Open CATIA V5
  2. Open a CATProduct with two parts (a pad with a hole and a
  cylinder).
      Let`s consider a lower face of the cylinder and an upper
  face of the pad (both of them normal to the axis of the
  cylinder and the hole in the pad)
  3. Click on Fix constraint
  4. Select the Pad
  5. Edit the Pad with the hole
  6. Add two publications: one for the lower face and one for
  the axis
     (for the publication of the axis, MB3 on the cylindrical
  surface, click on "Other Selection" and then "Axis")
  7. Edit the cylinder
  8. Add two publications: one for one face and one for the
  axis
     (for the publication of the axis, MB3 on the cylindrical
  surface, click on "Other Selection" and then "Axis")
  9. Click on Offset Constraint
  10. Select the lower face of the cylinder and the upper one
  of the Pad
  11. Change Offset value to 0mm
  12. Click on Coincidence constraint
  13. Move the mouse on the side face of the cylinder > the
  axis is highlighted > click on MB1 for selection
  14. Move the mouse on the side face of the hole in the Pad >
  the axis is highlighted > click on MB1 for selection
  15. Click on the Update icon
  Result: the constraints are correctly created.
  15. Delete the created constraints
  16. Activate Tools > Settings > Mechanical Design > Assembly
  Dessign > Constraints > Constraint creation > Use published
  geometry of any level
  17. Click on Offset Constraint
  18. Select the lower face of the cylinder and the upper one
  of the Pad
  19. Change Offset value to 0mm
  20. Click on Coincidence constraint
  21. Move the mouse on the side face of either the cylinder or
  the hole
  ==> ERROR: it cannot be selected. A forbidden symbol is
  displayed.
  .
  Expected behaviour: the Coincidence constraint can be created
  selected the published axis.
  .
  

Local fix

• empty
  

Problem summary

• Scenario:
  1. Open CATIA V5
  2. Open a CATProduct with two parts (a pad with a hole and a
  cylinder).
      Let`s consider a lower face of the cylinder and an upper
  face of the pad (both of them normal to the axis of the
  cylinder and the hole in the pad)
  3. Click on Fix constraint
  4. Select the Pad
  5. Edit the Pad with the hole
  6. Add two publications: one for the lower face and one for
  the axis
     (for the publication of the axis, MB3 on the cylindrical
  surface, click on "Other Selection" and then "Axis")
  7. Edit the cylinder
  8. Add two publications: one for one face and one for the
  axis
     (for the publication of the axis, MB3 on the cylindrical
  surface, click on "Other Selection" and then "Axis")
  9. Click on Offset Constraint
  10. Select the lower face of the cylinder and the upper one
  of the Pad
  11. Change Offset value to 0mm
  12. Click on Coincidence constraint
  13. Move the mouse on the side face of the cylinder > the
  axis is highlighted > click on MB1 for selection
  14. Move the mouse on the side face of the hole in the Pad >
  the axis is highlighted > click on MB1 for selection
  15. Click on the Update icon
  Result: the constraints are correctly created.
  15. Delete the created constraints
  16. Activate Tools > Settings > Mechanical Design > Assembly
  Dessign > Constraints > Constraint creation > Use published
  geometry of any level
  17. Click on Offset Constraint
  18. Select the lower face of the cylinder and the upper one
  of the Pad
  19. Change Offset value to 0mm
  20. Click on Coincidence constraint
  21. Move the mouse on the side face of either the cylinder or
  the hole
  ==> ERROR: it cannot be selected. A forbidden symbol is
  displayed.
  .
  Expected behaviour: the Coincidence constraint can be created
  selected the published axis.
  .
  

Problem conclusion

• THE PROBLEM WAS SUBMITTED ON :
      CATIA VERSION V5R19.
  THIS PROBLEM IS NOT REPRODUCIBLE ON :
  CATIA VERSION V5R21 GA level
  CATIA VERSION V5R20 SP5.
  Additional Closure Information:
  .
  

Temporary fix

Comments

APAR Information

• APAR is sysrouted FROM one or more of the following:

• APAR is sysrouted TO one or more of the following:

Fix information

• Fixed component name

  CATIA V5 WIN 64

• Fixed component ID

  569165000

Applicable component levels

• R520 PSN

     UP