HD87560: ASD: STOP MANIPULATE ON CLASH OPTION DOES NOT WORK WHEN USING M ANIPULATION COMMAND

APAR status

• Closed as unreproducible in next release.

Error description

• +LEROUX MT             -569165000
  -L222/FRE1CD-P1S1-09/07/29-14:20 -CE
  +LEROUX MT             -569165000
  -L222/FRE1CD-P1S1-09/07/29-14:20 -AT
  +LEROUX MT             -569165000
  -L222/-------P1S1-09/07/29-14:20 -AL
  +LEROUX MT             -569165000
  -L222/-------P1S1-09/07/29-14:31 -AL
  +LEROUX MT             -569165000
  -L222/-------P1S1-09/07/29-14:31 -AL
  +LEROUX MT             -569165000
  -L222/FRE1CD-P1S1-09/07/29-14:31 -CR
  S5> SERVICE GIVEN= 99  SG/99/
  Hello DS,
  Please can you analyse the trouble which is described below:
  Concerned Software..: CATIAV5
  Release.............: R19SP3HF18 and HF25
  Concerned Modulus...: ASD
  Concerned Hardware..: Windows
  Criticity...........: P1
  Description:
  ***************
  Assembly Design : "stop manipulate on clash" has no effect
  when using
  Manipulation
  scenario:
  **********
  1. Open the attached R17 product
  or create a new CATProduct and insert 2 new PART with one
  element/part
  2. activate the Assembly Design workbench
  3. select the "Manipulation" command and set with respect to
  constraints
  4. activate "Stop manipulate on clash" command
  5. drag along Z : you can move Part2 inside Part1: clash is
  not detected
  ==>this is a wrong behavior
  On R17SP4, it works correctly: clash is detected and
  manipulation is
  stopped
  Please, can you investigate on this trouble and deliver a
  corrective
  Thank you for your help and your cooperation
  Regards
  Marie Therese
  .
  

Local fix

Problem summary

• ASD: Stop manipulate on clash option does not work
  when using Manipulation command.
  .
  SETTINGS:
  None
  .
  SCENARIO:
  1) Start CATIA.
  2) Open the provided CATProduct or create a new
  CATProduct and insert two new parts with one element per part.
  3) Go to Assembly Design workbench.
  4) Select Manipulation command and select the with
  respect to constraints checkbox.
  5) Activate Stop manipulate on clash command.
  6) Select Drag along Z option.
  .
  OBSERVATION:
  One Part can be moved inside other Part. Clash is not
  detected.
  .
  EXPECTED RESULT:
  Stop manipulate on clash option should work correctly
  so that clash is correctly detected.
  .
  

Problem conclusion

Temporary fix

Comments

• THE PROBLEM WAS SUBMITTED ON :
  VERSION V5R19.
  THIS PROBLEM IS NOT REPRODUCIBLE ON :
  VERSION V5R20 GA level
  VERSION V5R19 SP6.
  Additional Closure Information:
  INCIDENT DIAGNOSIS:
  Stop manipulate on clash option does not work when
  using Manipulation command.
  .
  EXPLANATION:
  The problem is not reproduced on above mentioned
  levels. The Stop manipulate on clash option works correctly.
  .
  

APAR Information

• APAR is sysrouted FROM one or more of the following:

• APAR is sysrouted TO one or more of the following:

Fix information

• Fixed component name

  CATIA V5 WIN 64

• Fixed component ID

  569165000

Applicable component levels

• R519 PSN SP51906

     UP09/10/27 I 1000