HD96213: DRAFTING(INTDRAFT) / THE RESULT OF ?THREAD DIMENSION? ICON DOES NOT COMPLY WITH JIS STANDARD.

APAR status

• Closed as suggestion for future release.

Error description

• SCENARIO:
  1. Start CATIA.
  2. Open the CATDrawing containing a threaded hole
  3. Select ?File / Page Setup;? and click ?OK? button.
  This CATDrawing file is using ?JIS? standard.
  4. Click ?Thread Dimension? icon.
  5. Select the axis.
  RESULTS:
  The axis cannot be selected.
  EXPECTED RESULTS:
  In the case of JIS standard, JIS B0002-3(ISO 6410-3.
  The dimension line should be created from the center line and
  on the top of the thread.
  

Local fix

• empty
  

Problem summary

Problem conclusion

Temporary fix

Comments

• Dear Customer:  we have reviewed the problem report you
  submitted and determined that the function referenced is
  working within the scope of the original design
  specification. However we recognize the value of your
  feedback and will consider including resolution of this issue
  as a product enhancement in a future release, if one is made
  available.  We thank you for your input.
  Additional Closure Information:
  Incident Diagnosis:
  "Thread Dimension" function provides a representation
  compliant to ISO 6410 standards' conventional representation.
  However, it does not support the simplified representation
  which is also allowed by ISO 6410-3 standard, in 2 specific
  cases.
  Development Request Justification:
  JIS B 0002-1, JIS B 0002-2 and JIS B 0002-3 standard are
  reusing, respectively, ISO 6410-1:1993, ISO 6410-2:1993 and
  ISO 6410-3:1993 standards. Conventional representation for
  Thread dimensions
  is defined in ISO 6410-1 4.3 figure 14 and ISO 6410-2 4 table
  1.  ISO 6410-3 3.3 defines that "it is permissible to
  simplify the representation and/or the indication of
  dimensions" in 2 specific cases.
  This is an optional possibility, and using the conventional
  representation of ISO 6410-1 standard
  is of course a valid way of representing dimensions in those
  2 specific cases.
  "Thread Dimension" function provides a representation
  compliant to ISO 6410 standards' conventional representation.
  Support of simplified representation is an enhancement
  request which is currently not planned.
  .
  By-Pass:
  Please use conventional representation defined in ISO 6410
  standards. You may also use some text feature to figure a
  simplified representation.
  

APAR Information

• APAR is sysrouted FROM one or more of the following:

• APAR is sysrouted TO one or more of the following:

Fix information

Applicable component levels