HD67200: THE CATIA V5 E AND S ANALYZE/DESIGN VALIDATION COMMAND

APAR status

• Closed as program error.

Error description

• The CATIA V5 E&S Analyze/Design Validation
  Command returns an d error on the Validation
  Check
  Scenario:
  Send the PRC/GCO to CATIA V5
  Create a WP with a Piping System
  Place some Straight Pipes with no Bends
  Execute in the Piping WB Analyze / Design
  Validation
  Command
  Select the WP
  The Validation Check: Bending Bend angle less
  than
  minimum allowed produces a report with an error
  on the
  Straight Pipe not applicable to this Rule.
  On the Violation Report you getting on your
  Straight Pipes on
  the Validation Check: Bending Bend angle less than
  minimum allowed
  DSA was able to reproduce the problem in the R17
  Level. The
  problem exists with part type Pipe with bends when
  only ONE
  segment exists.
  For Part type Pipe the problem doesn t exist.
  DSA needs to update the Rule so when the Design
  Validation
  Tool is checking for bend angle criteria or any bend
  criteria, it
  needs to make sure that the pipe consists of more
  than one
  segment (more than 2 nodes) and make sure that
  there is a
  bend.
  .
  

Local fix

Problem summary

• The CATIA V5 E and S Analyze/Design Validation Command
  returns an d error on the Validation Check
  The CATIA V5 E&S Analyze/Design Validation
  Command returns an d error on the Validation
  Check
  Scenario:
  Send the PRC/GCO to CATIA V5
  Create a WP with a Piping System
  Place some Straight Pipes with no Bends
  Execute in the Piping WB Analyze / Design
  Validation
  Command
  Select the WP
  The Validation Check: Bending Bend angle less
  than
  minimum allowed produces a report with an error
  on the
  Straight Pipe not applicable to this Rule.
  On the Violation Report you getting on your
  Straight Pipes on
  the Validation Check: Bending Bend angle less than
  minimum allowed
  DSA was able to reproduce the problem in the R17
  Level. The
  problem exists with part type Pipe with bends when
  only ONE
  segment exists.
  For Part type Pipe the problem doesn t exist.
  DSA needs to update the Rule so when the Design
  Validation
  Tool is checking for bend angle criteria or any bend
  criteria, it
  needs to make sure that the pipe consists of more
  than one
  segment (more than 2 nodes) and make sure that
  there is a
  bend.
  .
  

Problem conclusion

• THIS PROBLEM WILL BE FIXED ON CATIA
  VERSION 5 RELEASE 19 GA level.
  NOTE THAT THIS PROBLEM WILL ALSO BE
  FIXED ON V5R17SP07 AND THIS PROBLEM
  WILL ALSO BE FIXED ON V5R18SP02.
  .
  

Temporary fix

Comments

APAR Information

• APAR is sysrouted FROM one or more of the following:

• APAR is sysrouted TO one or more of the following:

Fix information

• Fixed component name

  CATIA V5 NT>XP

• Fixed component ID

  569151000

Applicable component levels

• R517 PSN SP51707

     UP07/10/25 I 1000