Food for thought: The ‘Systems Engineering Club Sandwich’
AndyGurd 270001QKDH Visits (12789)
We’ve all heard the argument that a picture paints a thousand words, but I’ve always vividly remembered something I heard at a conference some years ago which was “I’d have taken a 1000 words over this one unreadable diagram.”
My belief is that it is not an either-or decision. You need both. Models can add clarity to requirements specifications and can bring together a more holistic understanding of what’s expressed in the requirements. Models can be walked through with stakeholders and with the right language and tools (like SysML or UML in IBM Rational Rhapsody), they can even be run to validate that what is captured in the model is correct, consistent and complete. But what if you have contractual requirements to manage, documents of regulations or standards to comply with, or complex performance or availability constraints – you don’t want to clutter your model with so much detail that it becomes unusable.
My preference is for a combination of textual requirements and models, that can be described by the ‘Systems Engineering Club Sandwich’ (references 1&2) where textual requirements, which form the layers of bread - and maybe a bit dry on their own, are supplemented by models that form the layers of filling – they are richer and more expressive, together forming a tasty combination to help explore and elaborate requirements, perform decomposition and allocation, and maintain traceability. I recently got together with my colleague Paul Urban to record a 30 minute webcast entitled ‘The Tasty Way to Tackle Complexity - The Systems Engineering Club Sandwich of Requirements & Models’ where we take a look at some engineering challenges, where requirements work goes wrong, how the club sandwich approach works and how to use requirements and models together effectively. So if this hors d'oeuvre has made you hungry for more, please take a look. Paul and I are really interested to hear what you think.
1. "The Systems Engineering Sandwich: Combining Requirements, Models and Design", Jeremy Dick, Jonathon Chard, INCOSE International Symposium, Toulouse, July 2004.
2. Requirements Engineering, Hull, Jackson & Dick, Springer 2004.