When I talk to users familiar with both WebSphere CloudBurst and the IBM Systems Director VMControl offering, there is sometimes a bit of confusion. It is not surprising. Both WebSphere CloudBurst and IBM Systems Director VMControl allow users to create and manage virtualized environments. That leads us to an oft-asked question: What is the difference between WebSphere CloudBurst and IBM Systems Director VMControl?
The simple answer is that the difference in the two offerings is the degree to which they are purpose-built. IBM Systems Director VMControl equips users with broadly applicable capabilities to create and manage environments consisting of virtual machines. These capabilities extend to PowerVM, z/VM, VMware, and Microsoft Hyper-V hypervisor platforms. IBM Systems Director VMControl is not necessarily knowledgeable about the software running in the virtual machine, but it does allow the user to manage that asset effectively.
Compare and contrast that with the capabilities provided by WebSphere CloudBurst. The appliance also enables users to create and manage environments consisting of virtual machines. The difference is that WebSphere CloudBurst is purpose-built to provide you with the ability to create, deploy, and manage virtualized WebSphere environments quickly and easily.
What does that mean? Well, on one hand it means that WebSphere CloudBurst does not treat the virtual machines it creates like a black box. In fact, it knows quite a bit about the software running inside those machines, and provides users with out-of-the-box configuration and administration capabilities for said software. WebSphere CloudBurst knows how to interact with the software in the virtual machines to do things like federate WebSphere nodes into a cell, create application server clusters, configure environments for optimal performance, apply fixes and upgrades, and more. The best part is you do not need to supply any of your own scripts to do this. In short, the appliance ships with WebSphere intelligence.
Beyond this WebSphere intelligence, WebSphere CloudBurst enables users to create customized WebSphere environments (from the operating system up) and codify those customized environments in the form of patterns. These patterns, which represent your very own WebSphere application environments, enable you to deploy your applications rapidly, repeatedly and with extremely consistent results. In addition, the appliance allows you to define varying roles for users, each of those mapping to traditional data center responsibilities (i.e. customizing the operating system, building application infrastructure, carrying out middleware customizations, etc.). Again, WebSphere CloudBurst was purpose-built with WebSphere environments in mind.
It is not all about comparing and contrasting WebSphere CloudBurst and IBM Systems Director VMControl. In the case that you are using WebSphere CloudBurst to create and manage virtualized WebSphere environments on top of the PowerVM hypervisor platform, IBM Systems Director VMControl is actually a required component. In this scenario, the two offerings are complementary. WebSphere CloudBurst communicates with IBM Systems Director VMControl in order to create and configure the virtualized WebSphere environment requested by the user. This image below depicts how the two products work in conjunction in a PowerVM environment.
I hope this helps to shed light on how WebSphere CloudBurst compares to, contrasts with, and complements IBM Systems Director VMControl. Feel free to reach out to me on the blog or on Twitter (@damrhein) with any questions I did not answer here.
IMPACT means new product announcements, and I'm particularly excited to point out the announcement for WebSphere CloudBurst 2.0. The new release features multi-image product support, support for Red Hat on VMware ESX, the new WebSphere Process Server Hypervisor Edition and much more.
You can get all the details in my blog post here, and you can watch an overview demo here. Don't hesitate to send me any comments or questions here or on Twitter @damrhein.
This week is a busy week getting ready for IMPACT next week. I'm looking forward to the conference, and I thought I would share a few things on my agenda. Naturally, my agenda includes the sessions I am running:
10:15 AM - 11:30 AM
TDC-2973A Meet the Experts and Demo: WebSphere Cloudburst Appliance
Come and meet the experts responsible for the WebSphere Cloudburst Appliance, and see a demo of its functionality in this informal setting.
1:30 PM - 4:30 PM
TDC-1369A Lab: Working with the WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance
Come and work hands on with the WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance to create your own WebSphere application environments in a cloud. The lab will guide you through using WebSphere CloudBurst to create and deploy WebSphere virtual systems in a private cloud. Youll learn how to create custom WebSphere and DB2 topologies by extending virtual images, creating patterns, and using scripts. You'll get a chance to work with the easy to use Web 2.0 user interface. Youll be amazed at the ease of use WebSphere CloudBurst brings to configuring, deploying, and running WebSphere environments in a private cloud.
1:30 PM - 2:45 PM
TAD-1370A Simplifying Development using Rational Tools with WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance
Are you looking to really simplify your WebSphere development and test environments - including never needing to install or configure WebSphere again? If so, come hear about how you can use the IBM WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance along with Rational tools like the Rational Automation Framework for WebSphere and Rational Software Architect to create a dynamic development and test cloud. With the integration of WebSphere CloudBurst and selected Rational tools, you worry about the application development, while WebSphere CloudBurst worries about the WebSphere infrastructure and your cloud resources. Come to this combination of presentation and demo to see how easy development and testing can be.
In addition to these, there are some other exciting WebSphere CloudBurst sessions on tap:
3:45 PM - 5:00 PM
TDC-2498A WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance at Lowe's
Lowe's is evaluating WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance (WCA) as a tool for managing their X86 and PowerVM environments in a cloud fashion. Come to hear how Lowes believes WCA fits into an enterprise companys cloud strategy. This session will discuss the work done at Lowes so far and the use cases planned for WCA at Lowe's. Attendees can understand how WCA is delivering value in an adopter's environment.
5:15 PM - 6:30 PM
TDC-1368A Introduction to WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance
The WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance delivers capabilities to create, monitor, and maintain private WebSphere clouds. It provides you the capability to quickly and simply create, deploy, and maintain virtualized WebSphere application environments running on a heterogeneous, shared pool of resources that make up your cloud. In this session, we will provide an overview of the WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance features and benefits and demonstrate the latest capabilities.
1:30 PM - 2:45 PM
TDC-1758A Building Private Clouds with WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance
Come join us as we discuss how the WebSphere development and test organization built a large private cloud from the ground up using WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance. We have lowered the entry requirement to get a meaningful WebSphere Application Server development environment (days down to minutes), saved costs by improving hardware utilization while simplifying our management of physical resources and topologies. We will discuss best practices for adhering to security requirements, creating reusable automation scripts for your applications and configurations and maintaining your cloud. Allow us to share our experience in using WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance to create our automated regression infrastructure, and to provide up-to-date deployments to our test team.
4:45 PM - 6:00 PM
TDC-1946A BSkyB's Experiences using the WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance V1.1
At Impact 2009, IBM announced the launch of the WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance. BSkyB witnessed this launch and were very keen to understand the device's potential. This presentation details their experiences to date, and their vision for incorporating the appliance into their organization. Details will include bringing the device in house, setting up the cloud, and doing deployments. BSkyB will also discuss the customisation process, and how they used the extend / capture and scripting capabilities to add content including WebSphere Process Server. The presenters will share their lessons learned as they continue their journey using WebSphere CloudBurst for agile environment provisioning and simplified WebSphere Administration.
10:15 AM - 11:30 AM
TDC-2063A Panel: WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance Customers Describe their Experiences
A panel of several customers who have adopted WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance will discuss their experiences with the product, and answer questions related to their experiences.
9:00 AM - 10:15 AM
TDC-1884A Using WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance in a PowerVM Environment
This session will discuss the concepts and issues associated with implementing the WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance (WCA) in a PowerVM environment. The components of the implementation including VMControl, IBM System Director, HMC, NIM. and WebSphere CloudBurst will be explained, along with their relationships and functions. This in-depth session will also provide best practices from early adopter deployments and performance experiences.
1:30 PM - 2:45 PM
TBR-2491A Customizing a Private Cloud for WebSphere Process Server Applications
Every enterprise has a unique set of standards when it comes to the applications that are deployed and the qualities of service that are required for those applications. Come to this session to learn some of the best practices around pattern customization and maintenance of the images in the WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance for your specific requirements. We will use the creation of a WebSphere Process Server double gold topology pattern to show these best practices. This session will also cover the practices involved with maintaining these patterns.
As you can see there is going to be quite a bit of activity around WebSphere CloudBurst at IBM IMPACT 2010. The lists above is not all encompassing either. Visit the IBM Impact site for more information. If you are registered to attend, be sure to visit the agenda builder website for the conference.
May is almost here and that means that IBM IMPACT is right around the corner. Just like years past, IMPACT 2010 will be a great chance to get valuable education and insight into IBM WebSphere software and software from across the IBM software family. If you want to hear how IBM software is leading the march toward a smarter planet, register now.
IMPACT 2010 will be a great chance to hear the WebSphere cloud computing story. There will be multiple sessions on the WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance. These include customer-led sessions, internal adoption stories, overviews, and much more. I'll be there running a hands-on lab and delivering a session that discusses integration between WebSphere CloudBurst and IBM Rational tools. Of course, there is more to WebSphere and cloud computing than WebSphere CloudBurst. We have several other sessions that will detail all of IBM WebSphere's work in the cloud.
If you are interested, I put together a short video discussing some of the sessions on tap for WebSphere and cloud computing at IMPACT 2010. I'd also encourage you to check out the social media site for IBM IMPACT 2010. On that site, you will find tweets, videos, and blogs about the conference. Don't forget to sign up, and I hope to see you in Las Vegas!
-- Dustin Amrhein
Yesterday, I had the opportunity to present WebSphere CloudBurst during the IBM Cloud computing for developers virtual event. I provided a brief overview of the appliance along with a demonstration, and then tackled some questions from the 150+ attendees in the audience.
All of the questions were good ones, and I wish I had time to address them all during the session (I will be answering all questions and posting them online soon). However, one of the questions stood out to me because of its relevance to how IBM uses WebSphere CloudBurst in their own labs. Paraphrasing, the question was "Can you share hardware resources (hypervisor hosts) between WebSphere CloudBurst and other components in your data center?"
Very good question. The answer is, of course, yes you can. I don't want to sugarcoat it because it does require thought and planning. Ideally, when WebSphere CloudBurst is using a hypervisor host, the appliance is the only thing acting on that host. However, when WebSphere CloudBurst is not using that host, then you can absolutely repurpose it for use by other components in your data center.
Our WebSphere Test Organization uses WebSphere CloudBurst to aid in their testing of our WebSphere middleware products. The capability to provision hypervisor hosts in and out of the WebSphere CloudBurst cloud is of critical importance to them. Like many organizations, they are resource constrained and must get the most out of their IT investment. They use the Tivoli Provisioning Manager to provision VMware ESX hosts for use by WebSphere CloudBurst, and then they use the WebSphere CloudBurst CLI to define those hypervisors to the appliance and do verification testing of the new resource. This allows them to easily expand and contract the amount of shared infrastructure utilized by WebSphere CloudBurst at any one time, and it means components do not have to statically lock down resources. I have a lot more information to come about our WebSphere Test Organization and their use of WebSphere CloudBurst, but I thought I would give everyone a peek at the kinds of things they do everyday with the appliance.
If you are interested in what I presented yesterday to the attendees of IBM's Cloud computing for developers event, you can check out their developerWorks Group page. In the Activities section, you will find the charts, demonstration, and a playback if you prefer to listen to the session. As always, I appreciate your feedback and questions.
The reason I suggest the application proxy approach is twofold. First, it affords you the ability of having custom interactions with the REST API. For instance, you may insert logic into the server-side proxy code that returns only a subset of the JSON data contained in the response from the appliance. Alternatively, in an effort to reduce the chattiness on your client-side, you may join JSON data from multiple different REST requests to the appliance to fulfill a single client request. You may even decide to represent the data in an all together different format than JSON. All of these options and many more are available to you if you implement an application-based proxy to the REST API.
The second reason I suggest the application approach is that it is easier, and seemingly safer, to not deal with user passwords on the client-side. If you setup your application proxy, you can configure it to retrieve the appropriate password from a secure location (like an encoded file) based on information passed along in the request. This means the password information is only present in the request (in encoded form of course) from the application proxy to the WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance.
The good news about the application-based proxy approach is that it is simple to put in place. I composed one using the open source Apache Wink project. The Apache Wink project is an open source implementation of the JAX-RS specification (and then some), and it enables you to develop POJOs that are in turn exposed in a RESTful manner. In my case, I had a single resource POJO:
The Apache Wink runtime routes any HTTP GET request whose path is like /resources/* to the getResources method in the WCAResource class. This method passes along information taken from the query string (the host name of the target WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance and the requesting WebSphere CloudBurst username), as well as the HTTP path information and sends it on to the getResource method declared as follows:
The getResource method above uses the WebSphere CloudBurst host name and the request path to construct the URL for the corresponding WebSphere CloudBurst REST API call. Next, it constructs an Apache Wink Resource object and sends the REST request along to the WebSphere CloudBurst Appliance. How do we authenticate this request? We use the WebSphere CloudBurst username (sent as a query string parameter) to retrieve the appropriate encoded password information. Once we have that, we construct the necessary header for basic authorization over SSL.
The application-based proxy shown here is simply a pass-through. It does not manipulate the data returned from the WebSphere CloudBurst REST API, nor does it map a single client-side call to multiple REST requests. However, it would be simple enough to extend it to do any of those things. If you have any questions about the code here, please let me know. I'd be happy to share more of the code, or talk about how and where to extend it.