In late 2010 the major theme of customer conversations was that every company was analyzing ways to save money and trim their IT budget. Those cost savings efforts slashed budgets by about 8.1% according to a 2010 CIO poll. The main method used was virtualization, combining all those UNIX and Windows environments that have sprouted up over the years. The new DB2 release comes along at just at the right time because Version 10 DB2 performance tuning solutions are potentially huge for many of the common designs, practices and DB2 performance tuning problems that are being used today.
DB2 10 Performance Solutions for Too Many DB2 Indexes Many DB2 index designs have far too many separate indexes defined on high performance tables. The DB2 10 Index INCLUDE COLUMNS feature provides the ability to consolidate some of those many indexes for improved DB2 performance. This will provide a CPU reduction for any data modification process and save storage with fewer indexes to manipulate and store.
Even if your design cannot handle removing all the indexes, DB2 10 also improves INSERT performance by using more parallelism. When INSERT SQL modifies a table with multiple indexes, DB2 10 does the pre-fetch of multiple DB2 indexes in parallel. By initiating parallel I/Os for the multiple indexes, the process is not waiting for synchronous I/Os, reducing the overall INSERT processing time. This cuts down the timeframe of possible contention within your system and improves DB2 performance tuning opportunities for all your applications.
DB2 10 Performance Solutions for Access Paths DB2 10 Optimizer SQL improvements are going to help everyone with their DB2 performance tuning efforts and especially applications and DB2 systems that have a large number of list pre-fetch access paths. These access paths are improved because the SQL Optimizer does more processing during the beginning of the data retrieval process Stage 1 SQL evaluation.
The DB2 10 SQL optimizer now evaluates scalar functions and non-matching index predicates during the Stage 1 evaluation of the SQL access path. Data entries that previously waited until the Stage 2 process are done early in the optimization process and dramatically limit the number of qualifying data pages and rows that have to be evaluated. By eliminating these rows early in Stage 1, I/Os and CPU of these additional data entries are not passed into Stage 2, significantly reducing and dramatically improving query elapsed time and overall query performance. This DB2 10 Optimizer SQL performance tuning solution alone will make a huge difference in all of your application’s performance.
DB2 10 Performance Solutions for All Applications
These and other features in DB2 10 provide immediate CPU and cost savings for any company seeking to improve DB2 performance tuning. With additional new SQL, XML and data warehousing features, DB2 10 provides more availability, design options and DB2 performance tuning opportunities for new or existing applications. DB2 10 provides performance solutions and a way for your business to reduce costs and improve performance exactly when your CIO and company need it the most.
Leverage DB2 Version 9 BASIC and EXTENDED Plan Stability Features
Last week I talked about leveraging the Version 9 DB2 Plan BASIC and EXTENDED plan stability features. I also commented that if you don’t have DB2 9 and are coming from DB2 Version 8 to DB2 10 that you can still save your DB2 access plans. If you are migrating from DB2 Version 8, move all your DB2 Plans to Packages and make copies of the Packages with different OWNERs or COLLIDs such as “SAVED” or something equally obvious. This way you can copy back, include the backup collection or manipulate your application to use these SAVED packages. Keeping the old SQL optimization and access path information is vital.
The following diagrams show how to setup a way save your SQL optimization access path and then back out a module. This worked for me a long time ago Version 3 or 4 and for a client with Version 7, so make sure you test out your setup and back out procedures. Then the process can be quickly executed by operations personnel with a REXX exec or library control process such as Endevor or other change management products. Since a picture is a thousand words below are two charts that illustrate how to set up a simple DB2 PLAN PKLIST access path preservation process.
Gene Fuh and Terry Purcell wrote an article describing this type of DB2 Plan technique and the CURRENT PACKAGESET options for protecting your access paths. "Insurance for Your Access Paths Across Rebinds" for further detailed explanation.
Remember DB2 Plan Stability with DB2 9 and DB2 10 is the best and simplest way to implement a method to protect your SQL Optimizer access paths. There are also software tools on the market for handling more complex backup and recovery situations. Use Version 10 DB2 Plan Stability as soon as possible, but there are several other techniques to protect your access paths and guarantee performance. My DB2 10 information has been put into a collaborative book with information from Roger Miller, Julian Stuhler, Surekha Pureka, DB2 10 for z/OS – Cost Savings ….. Out of the Box.
When getting my taxes ready every year, I review the previous year’s activity. Reviewing 2008 showed that the majority of my consulting was spent fixing and tuning DB2 Java based systems. This is not a big surprise since the trend and majority of my clients since 2005 have had DB2 Java performance tuning opportunities. Even in 2011, the trend of Java applications being built and implemented with DB2 z/OS and LUW continues at an ever-growing pace.
In most of these client situations, the majority of the problem has not been the database or the DB2 LUW or z/OS system; it has been related to the DB2 Java application processing. Java is the new workhorse and many systems are being implemented and not performing well. Working with my clients, I’ve discovered a variety of issues with these systems and over the next several weeks I will highlight the most common factors that kill performance for these new DB2 Java application systems.
Many object framework, architecture and programming pattern options are implemented with these languages. Given that there is no one object framework, architecture or application programming pattern that is right for every situation, there is neither a single right nor wrong way for performance success with your DB2 Java application.
(To be continued next week.)
Over the last three years, my clients have shown that multiple framework, architecture and programming patterns are usually implemented within the same project. The problem is the poor performance lessons experienced from the application implementation are not fully understood and the performance problems are continued and replicated into the next architecture, framework or pattern iteration, including DB2 Java applications.
Each application is different and each service or process within the application is unique. Step back and be flexible in your design patterns to understand that one or two architectures, frameworks or programming patterns are not correct for every situation. Your design should reflect the application requirements and the correct implementation for achieving the best DB2 Java performance might mean a variety or mix of approaches.
Objects within Java are great for flexibility and reuse. Java services and open source products such as Hibernate, iBatis, Ruby and techniques such as Java Persistence Architecture (JPA) and Data Access Objects (DAO) are great for accessing the DB2 database. Many of these techniques are common in today’s DB2 Java applications. My clients have experienced problems with these techniques when the application processing does not pay attention to the transaction integrity or the unit of work properly. When this happens the DB2 Java application processes usually have connected to the database multiple times, processed the transaction too many times or not committed or rolled back the transaction properly. These DB2 Java transaction situations usually manifest themselves in JDBC errors or poor referential integrity issues that developers blame on the database. Unfortunately, it is not the database but the application coding of the services that cause the problems.
In the coming weeks I will talk further about DB2 Java applications, their processing and issues that I have experienced with my clients. I know it will help you avoid some of these problems too.
Given the object model of Java and the relational model of the DB2 database, accessing data properly continues to be difficult for most DB2 Java application developers. Over the history of DB2 Java development, there have been many attempts within vendor products, interfaces and open source projects to bridge this object to relational data chasm. Many object to relational mapping of (ORM) solutions exist but few applications leverage them properly or efficiently.
The leading architectures providing good performance for my DB2 Java clients today, Enterprise Java Bean (EJB) specifications and Java Persistence Architecture (JPA) continue to evolve. Sometimes I have seen the open source Hibernate product implemented by DB2 Java projects looking for a quick database interface, but usually it is leveraged improperly and performs poorly. Sometimes the Hibernate interface even masks or creates problems in DB2 Java systems with its SQL handling and various parameter settings. Some clients have even written their own plain old Java object (POJO) interface to get to their DB2 data.
Any of these ways to get to the data can work and get good performance if the proper application framework, architecture and design pattern is matched with the correct application and transaction type. Working with IMS, IDMS, CICS and MQ systems referencing DB2 shows that very large databases with high availability have a variety of frameworks, architectures and design patterns. Just because an application is using an object oriented language such as Java, C## or .Net does not mean that performance or good database standards and principles should not be implemented or expected. Sometimes the application focuses on making the application fit the framework and more attention should be paid to DB2 Java performance.
One of the first standards and principles neglected in the DB2 Java applications that I have seen is that the application references the database too many times to complete a single transaction. While it is good to use your ORM database interface, the architect and application programmer should know how many times the ORM layer is used during each different type of the transaction. Since these ORM frameworks mask the database as just another object, many programmers do not know when their Java class or web service is firing a SQL call to the database. Within some DB2 Java performance problem systems, I have seen several hundred DB2 Java application calls to the database to complete a single transaction. This level of activity will never provide sub-second DB2 Java application transaction performance.
Comparing these new DB2 Java application database call levels against the other applications within any environment usually shows a substantial increase in overall usage. Sometimes the legacy transactions are only referencing the database 10-25 times while the new DB2 Java applications are referencing the database 130-175 times to complete a single transaction. Database usage during the Agile project development process or new scrum scenarios needs must be highlighted so everyone understands the overall performance requirements and expectations.
Most object oriented applications have their database calls travel through the network, web server and application servers making performance monitoring and evaluation even more difficult. Even though the next buzz word of cloud computing is supposed to cache and make magic of all these transaction performance problems, not even a cloud can make hundreds of calls to the database perform with sub-second response time.
Designing the unit-of-work for a given transaction entails many components. Different techniques and methods are incorporated depending on the components such as Hibernate, iBatis, JPA or Enterprise Bean technology to process the transaction. The Java transaction framework and the object patterns incorporated with the components also affect the transaction unit-of-work. All these factors together provide complete flexibility for today's Java developers.
Unfortunately, with this flexibility comes the responsibility to handle the transaction as effectively and efficiently as possible. For example, the various Hibernate, iBatis, JPA or Enterprise Bean technologies often shield the programmer from the database access. The database object is often passed through several methods or classes before it is used so a number of modifications could have already taken place. This same database object is also the same database SQL table access used for many different of processes and this is typical for the majority of the DB2 Java system reviews done recently.
This same database object is usually a SQL access that is usually a generic SQL call to a single table retrieving all of its columns with minimal WHERE clause filtering to obtain DB2 Java data. Alternatively, the DB2 Java SQL call could be using a unique key to get a single row from the table. In both cases the SQL is fairly simple. When it only has minor WHERE clause filtering, the database access is too generic. When the access is a unique key, the access is usually too fine-tuned to retrieve the group of data desired. Sometimes the DB2 Java processing passes multiple instances of the database unique access object and the Java method processes all of these database objects.
In all these scenarios, the SQL database access within the DB2 Java application does not fit the transaction processing or its unit-of-work. Generic access through the various Java persistence layers usually only provides basic performance for your transaction processing and usually retrieves too many rows for a given transaction. To achieve peak performance the DB2 Java transaction needs to access specific sets of database information and process them quickly. In too many DB2 Java systems this is a rare transaction processing situation.
DB2 Java performance is often a problem because the application processing is emulating the database which executes more efficiently or the processing is poorly designed. Either of these scenarios that my teams have found during performance or design reviews of DB2 Java performance of systems and applications always led to extended I/O activities and excessive CPU usage.
Too often, when the DB2 Java application was designed, the full scope of the eventual implemented processing was unknown. The specifications or even the coding of the backbone framework processing began before everything was known or so many additional processing add-ons were bolted on the transaction that the original design no longer fits the transaction and it no longer performs well. When additional functions are added into the transaction scope many times, the additional data retrievals are not added into the existing SQL processing. Instead they are coded as additional stand-alone SQL calls. This leads to SQL statement after SQL statement being executed during the single transaction of a DB2 Java application.
These add-on transaction functions typically add additional SQL to the transaction unit-of-work. This leads to the DB2 Java system transactions that seem to need hundreds or even thousands of SQL database calls to process their transaction from beginning to end. These large numbers of SQL calls usually touch and lock a large number of tables, inspect the data and finally perform the transaction processing. This situation typically uses excessive CPU and performs a large number of unneeded I/Os.
By not combining or enhancing the existing SQL to retrieve the additional data, the overall number of calls continues to expand and the DB2 Java database performance continues to suffer. The application design is needlessly neglected when these new requirements come along. When the changing requirements result in additional SQL calls with the application itself evaluating or combining new SQL data with an existing object data store, the result is more CPU usage and poor response time.
To avoid these types of situations in your DB2 Java application, understand all the data that is needed by your transaction. The application processing that combines or reevaluates data needs to be pushed back into the existing database SQL statements. DB2 does it much more efficiently. Retrieving additional data is bad for I/O, CPU, locking, and overall performance. So next time your DB2 Java transaction needs additional functionality don’t just add on, integrate your new functions into the existing SQL and designs of your DB2 Java application database processes.
In previous blog entries I have talked about transaction scope, how DB2 Java applications access the database too much and transaction units of work (UOWs) are not really analyzed properly .
Too often these days the design and development of DB2 Java applications are done in an Agile or SCRUM type of project methodology where short concise project deliverables are designed to deliver working transactions. These methodologies are good for transactions but sometime are not good at overall DB2 Java performance. Since the scope of the Agile or SCRUM sessions are individual transactions, the big picture of the overall business and processing objectives sometimes gets lost. This leads to transactions that only accomplish a small discrete piece of the business. Other transactions are necessary and retrieve the same master customer or product information again and again in order to complete the processing activity.
Database caching can mitigate and shield the impact on performance for repeatedly getting the same database information but cannot cache all the activity. When analyzing your various transactions, determine the overall business objectives and flow of your DB2 Java application. Combine standalone transactions or SOA services that use the same data keys as much as possible.
Another situation when a DB2 Java transaction runs into problems is when it must check something outside of the critical transaction path or its normal activity. For example, when a DB2 Java transaction uses seven different discrete web services to accomplish a complete transaction unit-of-work and after the third web service runs into a situation where something else needs to be checked. The processing then tries to resolve the situation by accessing another service and the new service experiences an error exception. In most DB2 Java database transaction environments the previous three services’ work would be rolled back and the entire transaction would need to be restarted.
Within good DB2 Java processing designs the extra situation checking would be moved out of the standard flow and services transaction processing. Starting another unit of work is understandable for these double checking situations only because we want to retain the integrity of the first group of services activity already completed. Analysis needs to be completed to determine the number of times the exception processing is needed and how many times it errors out with an exception.
One of the new features within DB2 Version 9.7, Cobra, is called autonomous transactions. This allows a transaction to commit a block of statements independent of an invoking transaction. This invoked autonomous transaction, implies that the work done is committed even if the invoking transaction itself is rolled back. This feature is perfect for this type of exception processing within DB2 Java applications and can be easily implemented within a web service structure.
Jeff Jonas' keynote session at IDUG Europe 2010 brought up several interesting thoughts and ideas. The sessions and conversations started and it seemed that Java, Hibernate and .Net systems have started to cause DB2 Java performance problems for a large number of companies. Many great hallway conversations pointed out how we all have great standards, code review, and EXPLAIN processes within our COBOL infrastructure, but have nothing within these other development environments, including DB2 Java. This is common and I always help clients with their DB2 Java performance by using Optimization Service Center, Visual Explain, the Optim Data Studio and Query Tuner products. All of these are great to quickly improve their DB2 Java, Hibernate and sometimes even .Net systems.
Java, Hibernate and .Net Projects
Several people wanted to hear about my experience with fixing DB2 Java performance, working with the Optim Data Studio products and how they can help with DB2 Java, Hibernate and .Net projects. We talked about how easy the SQL can get uncovered and then changed from dynamic JDBC Java processing to static SQL with the new IBM pureQuery product. For several companies their storage constrained DB2 systems can really use the reduction in the dynamic statement cache by getting these DB2 Java performance problems defined to be static applications. In addition, the bonus of getting a CPU reduction from Java, Hibernate and other JDBC connected applications from being static applications and not having to double check security, object existence and access plans is a huge business selling point for getting pureQuery implemented as soon as possible.
Be sure to join us at IDUG 2011 in Prague where I'll be presenting "DB2 10 Temporal Database Designs for Performance” on November 14th.
DB2 offers application designers new functionality for their data warehousing requirements. The new DB2 10 Temporal Tables provide a way to have a snapshot in time of the status of customers, orders or any other type of business situation.
DB2 Temporal Tables, with their built in functionality, automatically understand the business time or system time of the data entered into the system. This functionality is ideal for handling and documenting the condition of the any business aspect at a certain time. This functionality is driven from two new column definitions, BUSINESS_TIME and SYSTEM_TIME, defined within a table definition. Using these new time period columns within a DB2 Temporal Table definition provides a system-maintained, a period-maintained or bi-temporal time period for your data.
Many systems today have manual processes or utilities that manage or migrate their real time data to history tables. The new DB2 Temporal Tables with their new system time and business time columns can be used in conjunction with a user-defined trigger to automatically migrate transactional temporal table data to another user defined HISTORY table. Having these facilities built into the database greatly improves regulatory compliance, operations and overall DB2 performance tuning.
Separating out the real time transaction data versus the old data within your database using the HISTORY table requires planning and design steps. The separation of the old data from new data guarantees application and SQL performance does not suffer when your database is fully populated. Separation of the old and new data also helps DB2 performance tuning management so more resources can be delegated to maintaining base new transaction data where DB2 performance tuning matters for business operational success.
Over the coming weeks I will go through the steps and design decisions required to set up a Temporal Table. We will go through the SYSTEM_TIME, BUSINESS_TIME and a bi-temporal table design.
As the 2011 European IDUG approaches, it’s good to remember the annual North American IDUG conference in May where the latest and greatest information about DB2 was unveiled. The IDUG Board of Directors and especially the Conference Planning Committee did a great job providing qualified users, consultants and IBM developers as speakers to discuss their technical experiences with DB2 for z/OS and LUW, including the new release of DB2 10. DB2 performance tuning, application development and DBA topics filled the agenda and everyone learned the latest techniques to help their companies gain the competitive advantage
DB2 10 Beta program was the largest with testing by 24 companies and the most successful testing period ever for a new DB2 version.
The DB2 10 for z/OS software is only about a year old and is definitely being tested by an ever growing number of companies. The very nature of a new release requires the regular introduction of the maintenance for both z/OS and DB2 for the best stable environment and to fully leverage its performance tuning improvements. It is recommended that companies planning to go to DB2 10 should plan on at least quarterly maintenance cycles to fully incorporate all APARs, Hipers, and other fixes or enhancements.
DB2 10 continues to be enhanced due to some of the issues discovered during the beta program and other items that needed additional work. The DB2 for z/OS Version 9 Plan Stability feature is getting a lot of attention with its ability to help with production package access path preservation. The DB2 10 additional features of APCOMPARE and APREUSE are still being worked on. Even if these new enhancements don’t make it in the release, Plan stability continues to be a great feature introduced in DB2 for z/OS Version 9 for guaranteeing that access paths stay the same or improve with every new developer version.
For those of you that are looking for the DB2 10 White Paper the sign up link for the free download of the PDF from the IBM website is below. You have to sign up because they want to know how many people download the DB2 10 White Paper, but it’s free and you can opt out of any email spam. So download it today at:https://www14.software.ibm.com/webapp/iwm/web/signup.do?source=sw-infomgt&S_PKG=db2_zos_reduce_costs
As the European IDUG conference approaches, it’s good to remember the outstanding technical experiences discussed at IDUG with DB2 for z/OS and LUW from many user companies. The knowledge is from users, consultants and IBMers who have implemented systems and applications and have that extra in-depth knowledge of the multiple versions of DB2, including DB2 10 from the beta program. The presentations always provide a little extra tidbit that helps you avoid problems because speakers discuss the details of their scars from the front lines.
At IDUG North America, all the DB2 10 beta users’ presentations was really great. Most of the DB2 10 beta customers gave their impressions and testing results of DB2 10. They demonstrated why DB2 10 would be rolling into production environments soon. Some companies were even planning on consolidating DB2 systems or data sharing members because of the improved memory capabilities and since a single DB2 10 system can now handle almost 10 times more users as previous versions.
Several companies were evaluating DB2 10 against SAP and PeopleSoft applications. The testing of these applications has gone well and the companies were waiting for SAP and Oracle to get back to them with their certification of DB2 10. It seems the beta customers are testing more extensively and faster than these software companies. It really doesn’t surprise me that Oracle would be late to certifying their application since Oracle continues to lose customers due to the improvements on the mainframe and other versions of DB2.
Also the talk at the North American IDUG conference was that many Oracle shops that also have DB2 LUW are converting a large number of their Oracle instances to DB2 because of the crazy Oracle priced contracts. Saving money with DB2 LUW over Oracle continues as companies look at the performance and reliability of DB2. Expect that trend to continue as DB2 10 rolls out and companies are even consolidating their Oracle instances into their DB2 for z/OS environments.
I look forward to getting the updates at IDUG Europe.
Whether you are currently using DB2 Version 8 or Version 9, getting ready for all the CPU efficiencies in DB2 10 is easy. Your company may not be thinking about migrating to DB2 10 yet, but DB2 10 is getting huge industry wide support as the cost savings began to be realized by management. Everyone wants to save money and with everyone trying to squeeze their budgets, a faster adoption of DB2 10 is in your future. It is best to be prepared, so here are a few things you can do
in DB2 Version 8 that will make it easier to get to DB2 10.
Embrace System Managed Storage SMS
No, I am not Darth Vader telling you to embrace the dark side, but to let you know that DB2 10 catalog and directory use SMS. Using SMS is a hard thing to do for many companies and personally, I am not a real big fan of SMS. DB2 10 and additional improvements in storage have made me think twice and SMS may be more help than a problem. Being a performance geek, I recommend limiting or not sharing storage volumes within the DB2 SMS definitions. The SMS performance key, if possible, is to segregate the DB2 SMS definitions completely, yes completely, away from other storage definitions. SMS horror stories about the I/O troubles are well known and through my consulting clients I see SMS at the center of many I/O problems. Embrace SMS but be diligent guarding your DB2 system’s I/O performance and especially your DB2 catalog and directory data sets.
Sharpen Your Security
I am a big supporter of compliance, protecting data assets, security audits and all the security team’s efforts for protecting the company and all the business information. DB2 10 offers more privileges and authority granularity in your DB2 systems and security experts will need to embrace these features to separate out your data access, utility operations and day-to-day work. Start auditing your security usage of your systems area, various DBA support groups, different local and distributed applications, and analyze their needs. Do the activities require data access? Could the DB2 DBA work maybe been done using a different security level such as DB2 SYSOPR or another security authority? More DB2 10 security privileges and authority granularity improvements are going to affect your security profiles. Get ready and start the security analysis now.
Learn more about DB2 10 through the replay of Roger Miller’s and my 2010 webcast: DB2 10 for z/OS – Helping you improve operational efficiencies and gain competitive advantage. The webcast replay is available here…