Debater went to the movie – and now into business

Share this post:

Debater movieArtificial intelligence has been on a seemingly unstoppable march. Human champions have been bested at checkers, chess, go, poker, and Jeopardy. But all those are games – with rules and clear scores.

So, what happens when AI ventures out into the real world of human discourse and acts more like us? Where you don’t know what you meet around the corner, and where there may be no right or wrong – just pros and cons, and your sound judgment? That’s why we developed the Debater – to be able to meet and argue on any topic thrown at it under the sun….

This week, we broadcast “The Debater” movie at the film festival CHP:DOX.

The Debater movie is a rare, behind-the-scenes look at the maturation over almost 7 years of R&D work into a powerful new artificial intelligence. It tells the story of an eclectic team of researchers that dared to take on a so-called grand challenge – a challenge you think is almost impossible to solve and you have no clout how to get there when you start.

The difficult parts

In the movie and in the following panel debate, some of the difficult areas in interacting with humans are revealed: For instance, that humans are rarely convinced by evidence or rational argument. Working with and convincing humans are also about understanding how to connect with them in different ways, some of which are not as rational as others. Just as important as being able to know the facts, it is about understanding and adhering to the values, the morals and ethics of the humans (the audience) that the AI should support or convince. Without that, it is very difficult to gain humans’ trust. Harish – Debater’s human opponent and champion debate – was very surprised to learn that Debater could use moral arguments and rhetoric.

Apart from achieving new milestones in NLP (intelligent understanding and generation of natural language), the debater project has also led to a number of other very important outcomes for AI.

The Debater demonstrated drew knowledge and arguments from far more sources than humans could ever do.  In the movie, the knowledge base consisted of 400 million articles, 1000’s of generic arguments, and understanding of concepts – something that is easy for humans but very difficult for machines. Furthermore, it had to identify relevant arguments that supported its point of view and finally bringing it all together to construct a cohesive narrative. All that just in seconds.

Another capability that evolved during the development, in an attempt to make better connections on an emotional level – is to show some personality. As an example, by using humor, sarcasm, etc. But in context and at the right, acceptable level. Something you can also see debater do.

Potential use-cases for Debater

Important NLP capabilities from Debater have already been integrated into Watson services, such as Watson Assistant, Watson Discovery and Watson Natural Language Understanding.

We are now exploring further use-cases with companies and organizations giving them early access for tests and development.

Obvious use-cases for Debater would be decision support in connection with:

  • Strategic business decisions
  • Policy decisions (The Debater instance ‘Speech by Crowd’ was used to help politicians in the City of Lugano gather the citizen’s arguments for and against autonomous vehicles)
  • Constructing legal arguments in litigations
  • Evaluating healthcare treatment options
  • Supporting decisions in citizens case handling in the public sector

The Debater is about helping us make better decisions — particularly in the era of fake news and ideology echo chambers.

Harish says in the movie: “It is fine to disagree, but it is not fine, not to listen to your opponent”. AI like Debater can help us do just that.

The Debater project is about building an AI that can objectively, transparently, in line with our values and ethics make us see both sides and help us make up our own mind an informed basis.  It is not about replacing human decision-makers but to help them make better decisions.

If you would like to know more:

Check out: IBM Research: Project Debater to see debates, how it works, etc.

Stream the short movie on CHP:DOX: The Debater

Replay the panel debate with the film director Harry Spitzer, Noam Slomin (IBM Research Principal Investigator), Hayah Goldlist Eichler (IBM debating consultant) and Harish Natarajan (world champion debater). Host: Nikolaj Sonne (TV host and technology expert):

If you have any further questions, please do not hesitate to contact me directly at

Research & Innovation Executive, IBM Research - IBM Watson

More AI stories

How to act in the new regulation of financial sector

Our world is changing. Because of that regulators around the world are taking ambitious steps to improve the sustainability of the financial sector and guide capital towards sustainable economic activity. Especially in EU we are seeing a high level of regulations. These regulatory interventions present complex and sensitive legal challenges for financial sector firms, which […]

Continue reading

Private cloud or public cloud? New server technology offers more choice

In September, we launched the new IBM Power E1080 high-end server, for corporate use based on the  new Power10 architecture, the Power E1080. The server can – among many other things – handle a large number of applications and workloads securely, at scale and with highest availability. Going into the spring of 2022, we will […]

Continue reading

10 Questions regarding SDG to the company’s management and board

We have all together manged to create the most serious sustainability deficit and our greatest challenge is the ecological debt – a dept which we are running up by overusing and depleting our natural resources and thereby threatening our ability to meet the needs of future generations.  Worldwide, the strains on key resources, from fresh […]

Continue reading