2008 Director compensation narrative
Annual Retainer: Effective November 1, 2008, the annual retainer for non-management directors was increased from $200,000 to $250,000, the retainer for the chairs of the Directors and Corporate Governance Committee and the Executive Compensation and Management Resources Committee was increased from $5,000 to $10,000, and the retainer for the chair of the Audit Committee was increased from $5,000 to $15,000. Under the IBM Deferred Compensation and Equity Award Plan (DCEAP), 60% of the total annual retainer is required to be deferred and paid in Promised Fee Shares (PFS). Each PFS is equal in value to one share of the Company’s common stock. When a cash dividend is paid on the Company’s common stock, each director’s PFS account is credited with additional PFS reflecting a dividend equivalent payment. With respect to the payment of the remaining 40% of the annual retainer, directors may elect one or any combination of the following: (a) deferral into PFS, (b) deferral into an interest-bearing cash account to be paid with interest at a rate equal to the rate on 26-week U.S. Treasury bills updated each January and July, and/or (c) receipt of cash payments on a quarterly basis during service as a Board member. The Company does not pay above-market or preferential earnings on compensation deferred by directors. IBM had a retirement plan for directors which was eliminated effective January 1996, and the Company credited the PFS accounts with retirement promised fee shares equal to the benefits accrued under that retirement plan. For 2008, all directors made elections under the DCEAP to defer 100% of their annual retainer in PFS. Under the IBM Board Corporate Governance Guidelines, within five years of initial election to the Board, non-management directors are expected to have stock-based holdings in IBM equal in value to five times the annual retainer initially payable to such director. Stock-based holdings mean (i) IBM shares owned personally or by members of the immediate family sharing the same household and (ii) DCEAP PFS. Stock-based holdings do not include (i) unexercised options and (ii) any amounts credited to the PFS account in connection with the elimination of the retirement plan.
Payout under the DCEAP: Upon a director’s retirement or other completion of service as a director, (a) all amounts deferred into PFS are payable in either cash and/or shares of the Company’s common stock at the director’s choice, (b) amounts deferred into the interest-bearing cash account are payable in cash, and (c) amounts credited to the PFS account in connection with the elimination of the retirement plan are payable solely in cash. The payout of PFS is valued based on the average of the high and low sales prices of IBM stock on the New York Stock Exchange on the first day after the date on which the director ceases to be a member of the Board.
Termination of IBM Non-Employee Directors Stock Option Plan (the DSOP) effective January 1, 2007: Prior to January 1, 2007, non-management directors who had been elected or reelected as a member of the Board as of the adjournment of the Annual Meeting of Stockholders received on the first day of the month following such meeting an annual grant of options to purchase 4,000 shares of IBM common stock. The exercise price of the options was the average of the high and low sales prices of IBM stock on the New York Stock Exchange on the date of grant. Each option has a term of ten years and becomes exercisable in four equal installments commencing on the first anniversary of the date of grant and continuing for the three successive anniversaries thereafter. If a non-management director retires (as defined in the DSOP) or dies, all options granted to that director become immediately exercisable. Effective January 1, 2007, the DSOP was terminated. Therefore, the 2008 Director Compensation Table does not include any option awards. However, the table below entitled “Aggregate Number of Option Awards Outstanding” reflects the options outstanding under the DSOP as of year end for all directors in 2008.
IBM’s Matching Grants Programs: Non-management directors are eligible to participate in the Company’s two matching grants programs on the same basis as the Company’s employees based in the U.S. Under one of the programs, the Company will provide specified matches in cash or equipment in connection with a director’s eligible contributions to approved colleges, hospitals, cultural, and environmental institutions. Under the second program, directors can also make a contribution toward the donation of personal computer equipment to eligible primary and secondary schools of their choice. Under this second program, directors are required to donate 20% of the list price of a particular pre-packaged configuration, and the Company contributes the remaining 80%. Under each of these programs, directors’ gifts are limited to $5,000 per director, per institution, to a total of $10,000 in gifts per calendar year.
(This information reflects the 2009 Proxy Statement)
2008 Director Compensation Table
Fees Earned or Paid in Cash (column (b)): Amounts shown in this column reflect the annual retainer paid to each director as described above. A director receives a pro-rated amount of the annual retainer for service on the Board and, if applicable, as a committee chair, based on the portion of the year the director served.
All Other Compensation (column (c)): Amounts in this column represent the following:
- Dividend equivalent payments on PFS accounts under the DCEAP as described above.
- Group Life Insurance premiums paid by the Company on behalf of the directors.
- For directors who retired from the Board in 2008, this column also includes additional amounts as explained in footnote (1) below.
- Value of the contributions made by the Company under the Company’s matching grants programs as described above.
| Name (a) |
Fees Earned or Paid in Cash ($) (b) |
All Other Compensation ($)(1) (c) |
Total($) (d) |
|
(1) Amounts in this column include the following: for Ms. Black: $24,308 of dividend equivalent payments on PFS; for Mr. Chenault: $14,602 of dividend equivalent payments on PFS; for Mr. Dormann: $517,367 consisting of earned compensation and dividend reinvestments which had been deferred under the DCEAP since his election to the Board in 2005 and paid to him after his term on the Board ended in April 2008; for Dr. Jackson: $15,000 contributed by the Company under the matching grants program; for Mr. Makihara: $561,551 consisting of earned compensation and dividend reinvestments which had been deferred under the DCEAP since his election to the Board in 2004 and paid to him after his term on the Board ended in April 2008; for Mr. Noto: $1,466,383 consisting of earned compensation and dividend reinvestments which had been deferred under the DCEAP since his election to the Board in 1995 and paid to him after his term on the Board ended in October 2008, and $46,881 contributed by the Company under the matching grants programs; for Mr. Owens: $10,000 contributed by the Company under the matching grants programs; for Mr. Taurel: $12,880 of dividend equivalent payments on PFS, and $39,165 contributed by the Company under the matching grants program. (2) Mr. Belda joined the Board in July 2008. (3) After their terms on the Board ended in 2008, Messrs. Dormann, Makihara and Noto were paid the amount shown for each in column (b) plus the amount shown for each as earned compensation and dividend reinvestments in footnote (1) above. (4) Mr. Nishimuro joined the Board in September 2008. |
|||
| A.J.P. Belda(2) | 93,334 | 195 | 93,529 |
| C. Black | 214,167 | 24,403 | 238,570 |
| W.R. Brody | 208,334 | 2,325 | 210,659 |
| K.I. Chenault | 208,334 | 14,697 | 223,031 |
| J. Dormann(3) | 66,112 | 517,405 | 583,517 |
| M.L. Eskew | 213,375 | 7,778 | 221,153 |
| S.A. Jackson | 208,334 | 21,365 | 229,699 |
| M. Makihara(3) | 66,112 | 561,589 | 627,701 |
| T. Nishimuro(4) | 63,334 | 46 | 63,380 |
| L.A. Noto(3) | 167,195 | 1,513,345 | 1,680,540 |
| J.W. Owens | 208,334 | 15,559 | 223,893 |
| J.E. Spero | 208,334 | 11,470 | 219,804 |
| S. Taurel | 214,167 | 52,140 | 266,307 |
| L.H. Zambrano | 208,334 | 9,603 | 217,937 |
Aggregate number of option awards outstanding (both exercisable and unexercisable) for each director at fiscal year-end
As described above, until the termination of the DSOP effective January 1, 2007, non-management directors received an annual grant of options to purchase 4,000 shares of IBM common stock. Because Dr. Brody and Messrs. Belda and Nishimuro joined the Board after the termination of the DSOP, they did not receive any options and therefore are not included in the table below.
| C. Black | 32,000 |
| K.I. Chenault | 32,000 |
| J. Dormann | 24,000 |
| M.L. Eskew | 8,000 |
| S.A. Jackson | 4,000 |
| M. Makihara | 24,000 |
| L.A. Noto | 30,000 |
| J.W. Owens | 4,000 |
| J.E. Spero | 12,000 |
| S. Taurel | 24,000 |
| L.H. Zambrano | 12,000 |
(This information reflects the 2009 Proxy Statement)
