Software defect submission is more than a communication vehicle between development and system test groups. It is a method used to track defects, measure their scope and impact, and flush out related problems. Ultimately, it is a process that progressively improves software quality.
The System Verification Test (SVT) team for IBM® Rational® Performance Tester and IBM® Rational® Service Tester for SOA Quality has developed five scenarios that incorporate defect submissions "on the fly," either by using integration points (IPs) or by setting preferences within Rational Performance Tester. By following the steps in this article, you learn how you can use these two testing tools to create an efficient defect management process, plus how to get the most benefit from integrating a bug tracking tool into your test workflow.
IBM also offers several full-featured defect reporting and tracking tools, including IBM® Rational® ClearQuest®, IBM® Rational Team Concert™, and IBM® RETAIN® software. We discuss some of these in this article, too.
Internal defect tracking tools
Knowing what each of these tools offers is essential to smoothly integrating them into your testing processes.
Bugzilla is a web-based general purpose bug tracker and testing tool that was originally developed and used by the Mozilla project.
The Rational ClearQuest toolset provides workflow-based, web-enabled project lifecycle defect management and tracking. It facilitates control and communication from defect report to resolution.
Rational Team Concert
The Rational Team Concert collaborative development environment provides tools for agile and traditional planning, project status checks, reporting, customizable process support, work item management, change management, source code management, and build management. You can implement it in either a unified or modular manner. It connects geographically dispersed development teams to help increase individual and team productivity, compress development cycles, and deliver high-quality software faster.
The IBM RETAIN (REmote Technical Assistance Information Network) is a worldwide computer system that IBM employees, business partners, and vendors use to help solve the problems that clients have with hardware and software products. Although the Rational Performance Tester SVT team does not use RETAIN, it is frequently used by the IBM's product support representatives.
Value of customer scenarios to track defect reports
When evaluating product usability, one of the objectives of the System and Integration Test organization is to minimize the number of products launched and the clicks required to complete a user flow. Customers value a product's ease of use, so the more logical and less complicated the user flow, the higher the percentage of adoption.
Implementing customer scenarios to include the flow of defect submissions expands integration coverage. In addition, scenarios help through a strong demonstration of end-to-end user flows when you are using multiple IBM solutions. Integrating your defect tracking tool with existing IBM software adds value to your software development process in two key ways:
- User productivity: A successful scenario is one that mimics how a customer uses the products and has a simple workflow. When these elements align, efficiency increases, and this results in more time allocated to finding problem areas within the software.
- Integrated process: Using scenarios becomes an integrated
process solution for supporting an identified customer green thread
scenario. Integrating your testing software (whether Rational
Performance Tester or Rational Service Tester and Rational ClearQuest)
creates an association or linkage that accomplishes performance test
objectives and grants the ability to submit defects on the fly. This,
in turn, reduces the time required to separately launch your defect
tracking tool and allows more time to focus on the tests (performance,
functional, and so forth), as well as to determine the problem. An
integrated process also leads to the following positive outcomes:
- Productivity for the end user
- Process implementation
- Error reduction (which is dependent on valid input from the end user)
In determining your defect tracking submission scenarios as this article describes, it is vital that you are familiar with these IBM tools:
- Rational ClearQuest
- Rational Performance Tester
- Rational Team Concert
- Rational Quality Manager
The 5 scenarios
With a working knowledge of these, your team can make the right decision about which workflow to use.
Table 1. Defect tracking scenarios
|1||Rational Team Concert defect/work item via Rational Performance Tester/Rational Service Tester Work Items perspective||Rational Team Concert defect submission by clicking on the "New Work Item" button via Rational Performance Tester|
|2||Rational Team Concert defect/work item via Rational Performance Tester or Rational Service Tester||Rational Team Concert defect submission from test results via Rational Performance Tester|
|3||Rational Team Concert defect from test results within Rational Quality Manager (on a configured CLM server)||Rational Team Concert defect submission from test results via Rational Quality Manager after executing a Rational Performance Tester schedule (on a configured CLM server)|
|4||Bugzilla defect via Rational Performance Tester or Rational Service Tester||Bugzilla defect submission from test results via Rational Performance Tester|
|5||Rational ClearQuest defect via Rational Performance Tester or Rational Service Tester||Rational ClearQuest defect submission from test results via Rational Performance Tester|
Scenario 1. Rational Team Concert defect or work item via the Rational Performance Tester or Rational Service Tester Work Items perspective
This user flow has been identified as the most efficient and simplest way to create a defect on the fly after selecting to install the new feature (the Jazz Eclipse client for Rational Team Concert and Rational Quality Manager Version 3.0) and then creating a repository connection for Rational Team Concert within Rational Performance Tester.
Note: Rational Performance Tester Version 184.108.40.206 is packaged with Jazz Eclipse client v3.0. Previous 8.2 releases are packaged with Jazz Eclipse client v2.0.
- During the installation of Rational Performance Tester, choose to install this feature: Jazz Eclipse Client for Rational Team Concert and Rational Quality Manager 3.0.
Figure 1. Selecting the Jazz Eclipse client
- After installation finishes, launch Rational Performance Tester (full Eclipse).
- From the main menu, select Window > Open Perspective > Work Items.
- When the Work Items perspective is in view (Figure 2), you will see
You are not connected to a project area.
Figure 2. Work Items perspective (default) in Rational Performance Tester
- Click Create a Repository Connection to open the Jazz Repository Connection wizard.
- Enter valid information in the URI, Name, User ID, and Password fields.
Figure 3. Jazz Repository Connection wizard
- After connecting to a repository, click the arrow by the New Work Item icon (see Figure 4) to get a list of defect-related options (Figure 5).
Figure 4. New Work Item icon
Figure 5. Work item options
- Select Defect to open a New Defect Entry form.
Figure 6. New Work Item entry form
Scenario 2. Rational Team Concert defect or work item in Rational Performance Tester or Rational Service Tester
- In Rational Performance Tester, set Test Log Editor Preferences for
Submit, Search, and Open URLs to point to a valid Rational Team
Concert server. See the text that follows and Figure 10 for examples.
your jazz server: port number
- Search URL:
https://<your jazz server: port number>/jazz/web/projects/ RPT#action=jazz.viewPage&id=com.ibm.team.workitem
your jazz server: port number
- Submit URL:
- Open an existing test log.
- Click the Events tab.
- Select an event (at the root or page level) within the test log.
- Click the appropriate button to Add, Submit, or Search a defect. (See Figure 11 for an example).
Using the URLs specified in Step 1, the appropriate view is launched on the specified Rational Team Concert server.
Scenario 3. Rational Team Concert defect from test results within Rational Quality Manager
There are various ways to submit a defect from Rational Team Concert. The steps outlined here support the overall flow when leveraging a server configured for Collaborative Lifecycle Management (CLM).
Although clicking the defect icon in Rational Quality Manager to launch Rational Team Concert to submit a defect seems seamless, there are steps required to make this function work efficiently.
- Configure both Rational Quality Manager and Rational Team Concert servers to include friendship links. These links are entered through the Jazz Server administration.
- In Rational Team Concert and Rational Quality Manager project administration, add integration links between the Rational Team Concert and Rational Quality Manager projects.
After configuring both servers, proceed with the steps that follow.
- Configure the Rational Quality Manager adapter:
- Set preferences in Rational Performance Tester for the Quality Manager Adapter by selecting Window > Preferences > Quality Manager Adapter, as Figure 7 shows.
Figure 7. Rational Quality Manager adapter preferences
- If not already in view, open the Adapter view by selecting Window > Show View.
- Validate the connection to the Rational Team Concert server by clicking the connection icon in the Rational Quality Manager Adapter view. A message indicating a successful connection will appear in the Messages log (Figure 8).
Figure 8. Adapter connection status
- Launch Rational Quality Manager.
- Create a test case by selecting Construction > Create Test Case.
- Import your test script by selecting Construction > Import Test Script.
- Enter a project path or name.
- Select the test or schedule to run.
- Click Finish and Import.
- Open the test case that you created in Step 5.
- Under Table of Contents, select Test Script.
- Click the + (plus) sign, add the test script to the test case, and click Save.
- Select the test case, and click the Test Execution Record (TER).
- Click the green arrow > with the + sign to generate a new TER.
- Select to reuse an existing test environment.
- After TER creation, select the TER, and click the green arrow to run it.
- When the status bar appears, test execution begins and a Progress Summary is displayed.
- After test execution, in the event of a problem, select Defects
from the left panel to choose either of these options:
- Click Create Defect, as Figure 9 shows, to create a new defect report (this automatically launches a Rational Team Concert project on a configured CLM server).
- Go to Work Items to query existing related defects (this automatically launches a Rational Team Concert project on a configured CLM server).
Figure 9. Defect selection from the Rational Team Concert panel
Scenario 4. Bugzilla defect via Rational Performance Tester or Rational Service Tester
You can set preferences within the Rational Performance Tester to specify the default method or your tool of choice for submitting defect reports. By default, the preferences for the Test Log Editor (accessible in Rational Performance Tester by selecting Window > Preferences > Test > Test Log Editor) are automatically set to Bugzilla. However, the default URLs will automatically route the defect to the Eclipse project team. You can configure Test Log Editor Preferences to have defects sent to a standalone server setup and managed by you or your team.
- Install a local instance of Bugzilla. See the Mozilla wiki for instructions, or see the Bugzilla Setup Guide for an example.
- Set preferences in the Test Log Editor to specify the name of the server configured in Step 1. See Figure 10 for an example.
Figure 10. Test Log Editor preferences (default)
- Apply changes.
- Open an existing test log.
- Click the Events tab.
- Select an event (at the root or page level) within the test log.
- Click the appropriate button to Add, Submit, or Search a defect.
Figure 11. Defects pane within the test log
Based on the default URLs, the user is prompted to authenticate and proceed with the action according to the button selected.
Scenario 5. Rational ClearQuest defect via Rational Performance Tester or Rational Service Tester
Enabling the integration point between the Rational ClearQuest and Rational Performance Tester environments requires installing the latest released version of "ClearQuest Client" and "Rational ClearQuest plug-ins." What follows are the steps for installing client and getting the required plug-ins.
- Install the latest released version of Rational ClearQuest native
Note: If Rational Performance Tester already exists on your system, you will need to install the client in a different directory. Rational ClearQuest does not share a shell with Rational Performance Tester.
- Configure the Rational ClearQuest client to connect to a RATLC replica using Rational ClearQuest Maintenance Tool: click on File > Import Profile.
- Set up the replica for your site
- Provide a valid address for the SMTP server
Note: Without an SMTP server, users are allowed to complete the configuration and enter information for submitting defects but not allowed to submit or save the defect information. Therefore, this step is critical in enabling the ability to submit a Rational ClearQuest defect through Rational Performance Tester.
- Install Rational Performance Tester if it is not already installed.
Note: Rational Performance Tester Version 8.2 cannot be integrated with the latest released Rational ClearQuest Version 7.1.2.
- Install Rational ClearQuest plug-ins for Eclipse/Rational Performance
This is a key step. It is best to install the Rational ClearQuest Eclipse extension to your Rational Performance Tester solution by using the Integration Manager. By default, the Rational ClearQuest Test Manager perspective is hidden.
- Launch Rational Performance Tester in Full mode by selecting Start > Programs > IBM Software Delivery Platform > IBM Rational Performance Tester > IBM Rational Performance Tester > Full Eclipse.
- Open the Manage Connections window by selecting ClearQuest
> Database from the menus.
Important: This step allows the enablement of the Submit, Search, and Query buttons in the Test Log view. If this step is not administered, the buttons remain disabled.
- The RATLC replica (from Step 2) must exist in the available databases. Select the database, and connect.
- Switch to the Performance Test perspective and open a test log.
- Click the Events tab within the Test Log view.
- In the ClearQuest section, click the New button to open a new window titled "Create (ChangeRequest) RATLCxxx."
- Fill in the desired information and submit the defect.
- Click the newly created defect and click Open.
- The end user should be able to open the defect as if using the web-based Rational ClearQuest client.
- Click the Select button, and try to select a defect by following the dialog.
By using the approach outlined in these steps and scenarios, you have a pathway that enables you to use your Rational Performance Tester and Rational Service Tester for SOA Quality software to create a defect tracking process that is fully integrated into your test flow. As a result, you can help increase efficiency and productivity, while creating a more tightly integrated software testing process, too.
Thank you to the following people for taking time to provide technical reviews and comments: Dennis Moya, Qiang (George) Liu, Sanjay Joshi, Skye Bischoff, and Todd Merriweather.
- Browse the Rational Performance Tester and Rational Service Tester for SOA Quality pages on developerWorks for links to technical articles and many related resources.
- The developerWorks Rational software landing page, which is organized by functional categories, is also a good starting place to find out about other solutions.
- Stay current with developerWorks technical events and webcasts focused on a variety of IBM products and IT industry topics.
- Improve your skills. Check the Rational training and certification catalog, which includes many types of courses on a wide range of topics. You can take some of them anywhere, any time, and many of the "Getting Started" ones are free.
Get products and technologies
- Get free trial downloads for Rational Performance Tester and Rational Service Tester for SOA Quality.
- Evaluate IBM software in the way that suits you best: Download it for a trial, try it online, use it in a cloud environment, or spend a few hours in the SOA Sandbox learning how to implement service-oriented architecture efficiently.
- Join the Rational Performance Tester forum and the SOA Testing forum to ask questions and participate in discussions.
- Share your knowledge and help others who use Rational software by writing a developerWorks article. You'll get worldwide exposure, RSS syndication, a byline and a bio, and the benefit of professional editing and production on the developerWorks Rational website.
- Follow Rational software on Facebook and Twitter (@ibmrational), and add your comments and requests.
- Get involved in the Rational forums, groups, and Rational wikis.
- Connect with others who share your interests by joining the developerWorks community and responding to the developer-driven blogs.